So it was with some interest that I attended a public symposium last night on "Recessional Aesthetics: New Publics or Business as Usual," a discussion chaired by two crown princes of the contemporary art world, Hal Foster, a near-name-brand critic who holds court at Princeton and David Joselit, who holds court at Yale. The event was held in the old Dia Foundation space on West 22nd Street in Chelsea - Dia decamped several years ago to Beacon, a failing ex-industrial town upstate, where real estate was cheap. 'Ex-Dia' in Chelsea is for the year, in the absence of the new building owner's ability to do anything else with the property in this climate, a temporary art center called "X."
Well, who do you think won? New Publics or Business as Usual? In what could have been an evening of hard truths, fact-facing, frightening discourse, adventurous risk-taking, and the brilliant, combustive explosions of original thought that you would have imagined a room full of a hundred-plus accomplished art-types to be uniquely qualified to foster (sorry Hal), we got an evening that was as self-obsessed, beautifully stupid, self-consciously and uncomplicatedly entitled as a supermodel. Prince Hal (sorry Foster) and Prince David made the last few French Louises look like New Jersey turnpike tollbooth attendants, when it comes to being in touch with the public. But then, their public has been academe and the art world - and real estate agents in Hudson and Mattituck (and now possibly Beacon) - for so long that it's not absolutely necessary to talk to the rest of us. Tenure took care of that.
And, to give credit where credit is due, they're really good, as are their followers, at doing what they do. To be an important, celebrated, 'cool,' art ... thinker ... who ... thinks ... about art ... because ... art ... is really ... about ... everything ... (and ... anything) ... when you think about it ... you need to be soft-spoken (microphones do the work here), gently ironic (humor is such a human touch), you have to be able to talk in circles - really big ones - without pausing or looking down, but you also need to be flesh-eating, impatient and generally superior. You need to pretend you understand what people who don't speak your language are saying, but, only up to a point. Then you have to be decisively dismissive - in a soft, gentle, but rich and regal way. Kind of a 'Gandhi Wears Prada' thing. (Streep did it in the movie: low, powdery hate that you had to listen really hard for.)
Which is sad. Because I got the feeling, as I left the event - after an hour, they were still quietly mired in the third of ten save-the-art-world questions the panel-pair intended to address - that nobody was learning anything from the pain of the present Depression. At least, not yet. The saving graces for the common, wounded soul are probably to be found elsewhere right now, and not in the arms of contemporary art.
You can't turn a purse into a sow's ear, I realized.
Thank you for listening, ma'am.



